💡⚙️📈 Michael Gerharz on Breaking Out of Agile Theater and Communicating Real Value


Ever get the feeling you’re the “agile person” in the room—brought in to run ceremonies, fix Jira boards, or play Scrum cop, but never actually invited to shape real strategy? If that hits close to home, you’ll want to listen in on my latest conversation with Michael Gerharz.

Michael’s a computer scientist by training, but these days he’s known for helping leaders and teams find the right words so their ideas land, rather than getting tossed in the trash. We dug into why so many agilists get stuck in what I call Process Theater: going through the motions, checking the boxes, but never really influencing the game. Michael sees the same pattern—agile as theater, not progress—and he’s got some hard-won insights about why it’s so damn hard to speak uncomfortable truths in organizations that just want to “do agile” rather than be agile.

We riffed on three big themes:
– Why it’s so tough to communicate the real value of agile work (and why so many leaders default to checklists and ceremonies instead of outcomes)
– The human tendency to avoid nuance, especially when LinkedIn and the broader business culture reward black-and-white takes
– How to actually show up as a strategic partner, not just a tactical commodity

Michael introduced his PATH framework (Plain, Actionable, Transformative, Heartfelt) as a practical way for agile leaders to bridge the gap—ditch the jargon, speak the language of the business, and connect with what actually matters to stakeholders. If you’ve ever felt like your agile expertise is being wasted on the wrong conversations, this episode will give you new ways to break the cycle.

Get the latest episode of the Scaling w/ Agility Podcast on your favorite Podcast player, or watch on YouTube:

video preview​

​
Want to go deeper? Check out Michael’s book, The PATH to Strategic Impact, or grab his free PATH in a Nutshell guide for a quick hit of the core ideas.

PS: What do you think about the podcast? I'd love your feedback! Or even a quick word of encouragement to keep going...

Yours,

Scaling w/ Agility

Are You Struggling to Scale Your Organization ? Need agility but dubious of process BS/dogma? I share reflective, pragmatic, principled takes on how to approach scaling your organization leveraging the essence (rather than theater) of product operating models, agile practices and frameworks, and business operating systems such as EOS and OKRs.

Read more from Scaling w/ Agility

Is Human in the Loop the real goal with AI? It's a starting point, but I think the goal is to shift to Human in the Double Loop Maybe its even bigger than that. Maybe Agentic AI is the path to unlocking Human Agency A leader I talked to yesterday wasn't sure what their work will look like a year from now. We were finishing an AI coaching sprint in which they shifted from chatting with AI and using Claude Code for very specific tasks to unleashing agentic AI on several complex problems,...

Reader, I just wrapped up a great conversation with Clemens Adolphs, co-founder of AIce Labs, for the Scaling With Agility podcast. We dug into a question we both see more and more leaders wrestling with: Why do so many AI proof-of-concept projects look promising on paper, but never scale past the pilot? Clemens and I discussed some emerging practices for dealing with the pace and uncertainty of developing internal AI capabilities. Here are a few of the ideas we unpacked: — How to avoid the...

"Instead of Portfolio Management - Just Create Product Teams" - Have you heard that before, Reader? While I understand the angst against Portfolio Management Theater as a solution to Agile Theater... And while I agree wholeheartedly that the north star is to descale by reorganizing around value I find reality a bit more nuanced....Most leaders I encounter can't "just create product teams" their way out of decades of complex products and systems. None of them are Jeff Bezos - they don't have...